BAMBULAB Bambu Lab P1S 3D Printer, Fully Enclosed, Support Up to 16 Colors/Multi Materials, 500mm/s Fast Printing & High Precision, CoreXY & Auto Bed Leveling, Ready-to-Use FDM 3D Printers Large Print Size P1S (Without AMS) - 3D Printers
76

BAMBULAB

P1S Fully Enclosed

4.6
$419
Check Price on Amazon
VS
ELEGOO Saturn 4 Resin 3D Printer, 10" 12K HD Mono LCD, Smart Automatic Leveling, AI Print Monitoring, Large Printing Volume 8.62 × 4.84 × 8.66 inches - 3D Printers
76

ELEGOO

Saturn Resin 10"

4.4
$380
Check Price on Amazon

Our Verdict

BAMBULAB Bambu Lab P1S Wins

BAMBULAB Bambu Lab P1S 3D Printer, Fully Enclosed, Support Up to 16 Colors/Multi Materials, 500mm/s Fast Printing & High Precision, CoreXY & Auto Bed Leveling, Ready-to-Use FDM 3D Printers Large Print Size P1S (Without AMS) - 3D Printers

This FDM printer offers a superior max print speed of 500mm/s and a larger, more versatile build volume of 256x256x256mm, making it ideal for rapid prototyping and larger functional parts. Its capability to print diverse engineering-grade filaments like ABS and PA due to its enclosed chamber provides greater utility. The ELEGOO Saturn 4 is the better pick for users prioritizing ultra-fine detail, intricate models, and smoother surface finishes for aesthetic purposes, especially given its lower $379.99 price point.

Bottom Line: BAMBULAB Bambu Lab P1S is the better choice. This FDM printer offers a superior max print speed of 500mm/s and a larger, more versatile build volume of 256x256x256mm, making it ideal for rapid prototyping and larger functional parts.

In-Depth Analysis

How they compare in practice

The BAMBULAB Bambu Lab P1S and ELEGOO Saturn 4 represent two distinct philosophies in 3D printing: speed and material versatility versus ultra-fine detail. The Bambu Lab P1S, an FDM printer, is a workhorse for rapid production. Its standout feature is a blazing 500mm/s max print speed, allowing users to complete models significantly faster than typical FDM printers. This translates directly into quicker design iterations and higher output for functional parts. The enclosed build chamber, measuring a generous 256x256x256mm, is critical for successfully printing advanced filaments like ABS, PA, and PC by maintaining a stable internal temperature, thus minimizing warping.

Conversely, the ELEGOO Saturn 4, a resin (MSLA) printer, excels where the P1S makes compromises: extreme detail and smooth finishes. Equipped with a 10-inch 12K HD Mono LCD, it can reproduce intricate textures and fine features that FDM printers simply cannot match, making it ideal for miniatures, jewelry, or highly aesthetic prototypes. While resin prints are inherently slower due to the layer-by-layer curing process (hence a '0' for typical print speed metrics), the resulting output quality is unparalleled. Both printers feature auto bed leveling, simplifying setup and ensuring consistent first layers, a convenience that enhances the user experience for both FDM and resin novices.

The real-world difference lies in application. The P1S, at $419.0, is for creators who need strong, functional components quickly and frequently. Its large build volume and FDM material range are conducive to larger parts or batches. The Saturn 4, priced at $379.99, offers a more affordable entry into high-resolution printing, but users must account for the additional costs and processes associated with resin, such as washing, curing, and managing fumes (which it lacks integrated filtration for). While the P1S requires a separate AMS unit for multi-color printing, its core performance makes it a highly efficient machine for a broad range of FDM applications, whereas the Saturn 4 is a specialist, delivering exquisite detail for specific niche demands.

Key Differences

The most significant spec differences at a glance

500

Max Print Speed Mm S

100% more
0

Advantages

Where each product wins

BAMBULAB Bambu Lab P1S 3D Printer, Fully Enclosed, Support Up to 16 Colors/Multi Materials, 500mm/s Fast Printing & High Precision, CoreXY & Auto Bed Leveling, Ready-to-Use FDM 3D Printers Large Print Size P1S (Without AMS) - 3D Printers

BAMBULAB

  • Max Print Speed Mm S: 100% higher (500.0 vs 0)

Which to Pick for Your Situation

Concrete scenarios with a clear recommendation

For rapid prototyping of functional parts

BAMBULAB

The Bambu Lab P1S boasts a 500mm/s max print speed and supports robust FDM filaments like ABS, perfect for quick, strong functional prototypes.

For highly detailed miniatures or figurines

ELEGOO

The Elegoo Saturn 4's 10-inch 12K HD Mono LCD delivers ultra-fine resolution and smooth surfaces, ideal for intricate aesthetic models.

For printing large single-piece objects

BAMBULAB

With a build volume of 256x256x256mm, the Bambu Lab P1S offers a larger and more versatile FDM printing space compared to the resin printer.

For a budget-conscious buyer prioritizing resolution

ELEGOO

The Elegoo Saturn 4 is more affordable at $379.99 and provides exceptional 12K detail, though resin consumables might increase long-term costs.

Who Should Buy Which?

Find the right product for your needs

BAMBULAB Bambu Lab P1S 3D Printer, Fully Enclosed, Support Up to 16 Colors/Multi Materials, 500mm/s Fast Printing & High Precision, CoreXY & Auto Bed Leveling, Ready-to-Use FDM 3D Printers Large Print Size P1S (Without AMS) - 3D Printers

Buy BAMBULAB if...

Bambu Lab P1S 3D

The ideal buyer for the BAMBULAB Bambu Lab P1S is a hobbyist, small business owner, or educator focused on creating functional parts, prototypes, or larger models with speed and material versatility. They prioritize rapid iteration and the production of robust objects that can withstand real-world use. With its impressive 500mm/s max print speed, they can quickly turn designs into physical objects, making it excellent for prototyping or producing batches of components. The 256x256x256mm build volume allows for substantial part sizes, and the enclosed chamber is crucial for reliably printing engineering filaments like ABS, PA, and PC, which require stable temperatures to prevent warping. This buyer values reliability and consistent quality enabled by auto bed leveling, and is willing to invest $419.0 for a powerful FDM machine, understanding that ultra-fine aesthetic details are secondary to strength and speed. They are not looking to print highly intricate miniatures where resin printers excel.

ELEGOO Saturn 4 Resin 3D Printer, 10" 12K HD Mono LCD, Smart Automatic Leveling, AI Print Monitoring, Large Printing Volume 8.62 × 4.84 × 8.66 inches - 3D Printers

Buy ELEGOO if...

ELEGOO Saturn 4 Resin

The ideal buyer for the ELEGOO Saturn 4 is an enthusiast or professional whose primary focus is achieving exceptionally high detail and smooth surface finishes on models. This includes miniature painters, jewelers, model makers, or anyone needing aesthetically flawless prints. They prioritize the incredible resolution offered by the 10" 12K HD Mono LCD over print speed for larger objects. With smart automatic leveling, the Saturn 4 simplifies the printing process, allowing users to focus on design and post-processing. Its build volume of 218.948x122.936x219.964mm is ample for intricate resin prints. At $379.99, it offers a more accessible entry point into high-resolution resin printing, even if resin consumables and post-processing steps (like washing and curing) add to the overall effort. This buyer accepts the slower layer-by-layer printing and the need for proper ventilation, as their main goal is stunning visual fidelity rather than industrial-strength functional parts.

Spec Comparison

9 specs compared

Specification
BAMBULAB Bambu Lab P1S 3D Printer, Fully Enclosed, Support Up to 16 Colors/Multi Materials, 500mm/s Fast Printing & High Precision, CoreXY & Auto Bed Leveling, Ready-to-Use FDM 3D Printers Large Print Size P1S (Without AMS) - 3D Printers
BAMBULAB Bambu Lab P1S
ELEGOO Saturn 4 Resin 3D Printer, 10" 12K HD Mono LCD, Smart Automatic Leveling, AI Print Monitoring, Large Printing Volume 8.62 × 4.84 × 8.66 inches - 3D Printers
ELEGOO Saturn 4 Resin
Price$419$380
Rating4.6(442)4.4(1.5k)
Build Volume mm256x256x256218.948x122.936x219.964
Max Print Speed mm S5000
Leveling TypeAutoAuto
EnclosedYesYes
Weight38.9 lbs
Printer TypeFDMResin (SLA/MSLA)
Multi Color SupportYes
Model NumberSATURN 4
Resume PrintYes

Swipe horizontally to see all columns

Pros & Cons

Quick overview of strengths and weaknesses

BAMBULAB Bambu Lab P1S 3D Printer, Fully Enclosed, Support Up to 16 Colors/Multi Materials, 500mm/s Fast Printing & High Precision, CoreXY & Auto Bed Leveling, Ready-to-Use FDM 3D Printers Large Print Size P1S (Without AMS)

BAMBULAB Bambu Lab

Pros
  • 500mm/s max print speed for faster output.
  • Enclosed build chamber handles advanced filaments.
  • Auto bed leveling for consistent first layers.
  • Quick setup: ready to print in 15 minutes.
Cons
  • Multi-color printing needs separate AMS unit.
  • Does not support carbon or glass fiber filaments.
ELEGOO Saturn 4 Resin 3D Printer, 10" 12K HD Mono LCD, Smart Automatic Leveling, AI Print Monitoring, Large Printing Volume 8.62 × 4.84 × 8.66 inches

ELEGOO Saturn 4

Pros
  • 12K LCD for ultra-fine model detail
  • Auto-leveling simplifies initial setup
  • 92% light uniformity ensures consistent prints
  • Large 219x123x220mm build volume
Cons
  • Large prints consume significant resin volume
  • 12K resolution may lead to longer print times
  • No integrated air filtration for fumes

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about this comparison

Can the Bambu Lab P1S print in multiple colors?

Yes, the Bambu Lab P1S supports up to 16 colors/multi-materials, but this functionality requires the separate purchase of an AMS (Automatic Material System) unit.

What kind of detail can I expect from the ELEGOO Saturn 4?

The Saturn 4 features a 10" 12K HD Mono LCD, capable of producing extremely fine details and smooth surfaces, making it ideal for intricate models and miniatures.

Which printer is generally faster for completing models?

The Bambu Lab P1S, as an FDM printer, has a max print speed of 500mm/s, allowing for significantly faster object completion compared to the layer-by-layer curing of the resin-based Elegoo Saturn 4.

What materials can the Bambu Lab P1S print?

It supports diverse FDM filaments including PLA, ABS, PA, and PC. Its enclosed chamber effectively aids in printing warp-prone engineering materials for better results.

Does the Elegoo Saturn 4 require manual bed leveling?

No, the Elegoo Saturn 4 features smart automatic leveling, which simplifies the initial setup process and ensures consistent first layers without manual intervention.

What are the key differences in build volume?

The Bambu Lab P1S offers a 256x256x256mm build volume. The Elegoo Saturn 4 provides 218.948x122.936x219.964mm, focusing on tall, detailed resin prints rather than expansive FDM objects.

Explore Other Categories

Popular comparisons across the site

Ask AI

Get instant answers about specs

Get the Deets

Ask our AI assistant

Ask Deets anything!