BenQ W4100i 4K HDR Smart Home Theater Projector, 3200 Lumens, 100% DCI-P3, Rec.709, Factory-Calibrated, Android TV with Netflix, 4-Way Lens Shift, HDR10+ & HLG Support, LED Long Lifespan - Home Projectors
59

BenQ

W4100i 4K HDR

4.6
$2799
Check Price on Amazon
VS
Hisense PX3-PRO Ultra Short Throw Triple Laser Projector, 4K UHD, 80” – 150”, 3,000 Lumens, 3000:1 Contrast, Dolby Vision & Atmos, IMAX Enhanced, 240 High Refresh Rate, Google TV, Designed for Xbox - Home Projectors
52

Hisense

PX3-PRO Ultra Short

4.2
$2998
Check Price on Amazon

Our Verdict

BenQ W4100i Wins

BenQ W4100i 4K HDR Smart Home Theater Projector, 3200 Lumens, 100% DCI-P3, Rec.709, Factory-Calibrated, Android TV with Netflix, 4-Way Lens Shift, HDR10+ & HLG Support, LED Long Lifespan - Home Projectors

It delivers a superior cinematic experience with its higher 3200 lumens brightness and 100% DCI-P3 color gamut, all at a more accessible $2799 price point. Its lens shift and zoom also offer greater installation flexibility for dedicated home theater setups. The Hisense PX3-PRO is the better pick for serious gamers or those needing an ultra-short throw projector in a multi-purpose living space due to its 240Hz refresh rate and near-wall placement convenience.

Bottom Line: BenQ W4100i is the better choice. It delivers a superior cinematic experience with its higher 3200 lumens brightness and 100% DCI-P3 color gamut, all at a more accessible $2799 price point.

In-Depth Analysis

How they compare in practice

The BenQ W4100i and Hisense PX3-PRO represent distinct philosophies in the 4K projector market. The BenQ W4100i is a traditional long-throw projector, excelling in dedicated dark room environments. Its LED light source, rated for over 10 years, offers consistent brightness and color without lamp replacement concerns, along with instant on/off capabilities. With 3200 lumens and 100% DCI-P3 color coverage, it aims for a precise, vibrant, and bright cinematic image, further aided by features like 4-way lens shift and 1.3x zoom for easier installation and fine-tuning.

In contrast, the Hisense PX3-PRO is an Ultra Short Throw (UST) projector, meaning it sits very close to the wall or screen, ideal for living rooms where a traditional projector setup isn't feasible. Its triple laser light source offers an even wider 110% BT.2020 color gamut, potentially delivering a broader spectrum of colors, though DCI-P3 is the standard for cinema. The PX3-PRO's standout feature is its 240Hz high refresh rate and 'Designed for Xbox' designation, making it a strong contender for serious gamers seeking fluid motion. However, its 3000 lumens brightness is slightly lower than the BenQ's 3200, and optimal performance generally requires an Ambient Light Rejecting (ALR) screen, adding to the overall cost and setup complexity.

The real-world implications are significant. The BenQ provides unparalleled flexibility in placement and fine-tuning for a fully immersive, traditional home theater. Its higher brightness ensures a punchy image, and 100% DCI-P3 ensures accurate cinematic color. The Hisense, while fantastic for saving space and gaming, requires precise positioning for its UST nature and might necessitate an expensive ALR screen to combat ambient light effectively. Its lower stated contrast ratio of 3000:1 compared to BenQ's potential (though unspecified) dynamic contrast could also mean slightly less 'pop' in very dark scenes. Ultimately, the BenQ offers superior cinematic value and installation flexibility for dedicated spaces, while the Hisense offers cutting-edge gaming and space-saving convenience at a slightly higher price.

Key Differences

The most significant spec differences at a glance

3,200

Brightness Ansi Lumens

7% more
3,000

Advantages

Where each product wins

BenQ W4100i 4K HDR Smart Home Theater Projector, 3200 Lumens, 100% DCI-P3, Rec.709, Factory-Calibrated, Android TV with Netflix, 4-Way Lens Shift, HDR10+ & HLG Support, LED Long Lifespan - Home Projectors

BenQ

  • Brightness Ansi Lumens: 7% higher (3200 vs 3000)

Which to Pick for Your Situation

Concrete scenarios with a clear recommendation

For a dedicated home theater room

BenQ

The BenQ W4100i's 3200 lumens, 100% DCI-P3 color, and lens shift provide an uncompromised, flexible cinematic experience in controlled lighting.

For serious console or PC gaming

Hisense

The Hisense PX3-PRO boasts a 240Hz refresh rate and is 'Designed for Xbox,' indicating superior performance for fast-paced gaming.

For a multi-purpose living room

Hisense

Its Ultra Short Throw design allows the Hisense to project large images from very close to the wall, integrating seamlessly into shared spaces.

For value-conscious 4K cinematic quality

BenQ

The BenQ W4100i offers native 4K, 3200 lumens, and 100% DCI-P3 color at a more affordable $2799 price point.

Who Should Buy Which?

Find the right product for your needs

BenQ W4100i 4K HDR Smart Home Theater Projector, 3200 Lumens, 100% DCI-P3, Rec.709, Factory-Calibrated, Android TV with Netflix, 4-Way Lens Shift, HDR10+ & HLG Support, LED Long Lifespan - Home Projectors

Buy BenQ if...

BenQ W4100i 4K HDR

The BenQ W4100i is ideal for the dedicated home theater enthusiast who prioritizes uncompromised image quality and flexible installation within a controlled, dark viewing environment. This buyer is likely setting up a permanent projector solution and appreciates the fine-tuning capabilities of 4-way lens shift and 1.3x zoom for perfect screen alignment. They seek vibrant, accurate colors, explicitly valuing the 100% DCI-P3 color gamut for cinematic content, combined with the robust 3200 ANSI lumens for a bright, impactful picture. While budget-conscious, they recognize the value in paying $2799 for native 4K resolution and a long-lasting LED light source, rather than a lamp-based system. This individual is less concerned with ultra-short throw convenience or extreme gaming refresh rates, prioritizing pure picture fidelity and the classic cinematic experience above all else.

Hisense PX3-PRO Ultra Short Throw Triple Laser Projector, 4K UHD, 80” – 150”, 3,000 Lumens, 3000:1 Contrast, Dolby Vision & Atmos, IMAX Enhanced, 240 High Refresh Rate, Google TV, Designed for Xbox - Home Projectors

Buy Hisense if...

Hisense PX3-PRO Ultra Short

The Hisense PX3-PRO is perfectly suited for the modern, tech-savvy consumer who wants a large-screen experience without the traditional projector setup hassle or for avid gamers. This buyer lives in a multi-purpose living space and needs an Ultra Short Throw projector that can sit close to the wall, offering a minimalist aesthetic and avoiding ceiling mounts or long cable runs. Their priorities include cutting-edge gaming performance, evident in the 240Hz refresh rate and 'Designed for Xbox' feature, ensuring smooth, low-latency gameplay. They also appreciate the wide color reproduction of 110% BT.2020 from its triple laser light source, providing vivid images. While willing to spend $2997.97, they understand an additional investment in an ALR screen might be necessary for optimal daytime viewing. They are willing to trade some installation flexibility for the convenience of UST and superior gaming capabilities.

Spec Comparison

6 specs compared

Specification
BenQ W4100i 4K HDR Smart Home Theater Projector, 3200 Lumens, 100% DCI-P3, Rec.709, Factory-Calibrated, Android TV with Netflix, 4-Way Lens Shift, HDR10+ & HLG Support, LED Long Lifespan - Home Projectors
BenQ W4100i 4K HDR
Hisense PX3-PRO Ultra Short Throw Triple Laser Projector, 4K UHD, 80” – 150”, 3,000 Lumens, 3000:1 Contrast, Dolby Vision & Atmos, IMAX Enhanced, 240 High Refresh Rate, Google TV, Designed for Xbox - Home Projectors
Hisense PX3-PRO Ultra Short
Price$2799$2998
Rating4.6(30)4.2(104)
Brightness Ansi Lumens32003000
Native ResolutionNative 4KNative 4K
Lens ShiftYes
Hdr SupportYesYes
Light SourceLEDLaser
Contrast Ratio3000:1

Swipe horizontally to see all columns

Pros & Cons

Quick overview of strengths and weaknesses

BenQ W4100i 4K HDR Smart Home Theater Projector, 3200 Lumens, 100% DCI-P3, Rec.709, Factory-Calibrated, Android TV with Netflix, 4-Way Lens Shift, HDR10+ & HLG Support, LED Long Lifespan

BenQ W4100i 4K

Pros
  • Native 4K UHD resolution (3840x2160 pixels)
  • Achieves 100% DCI-P3 color gamut
  • LED light source rated for 10+ years
  • 3200 lumens provides high brightness
Cons
  • Requires controlled dark environment for best picture
  • Precise alignment and focus needed for optimal setup
  • No explicit mention of low input lag for gaming
  • Fixed LED light source, not user-replaceable
Hisense PX3-PRO Ultra Short Throw Triple Laser Projector, 4K UHD, 80” – 150”, 3,000 Lumens, 3000:1 Contrast, Dolby Vision & Atmos, IMAX Enhanced, 240 High Refresh Rate, Google TV, Designed for Xbox

Hisense PX3-PRO Ultra

Pros
  • Projects 80-150 inches from short distance.
  • Native 4K resolution with AI upscaling.
  • 3000 lumens produces bright images.
  • Achieves 110% BT.2020 color gamut.
Cons
  • Optimal performance requires ALR screen.
  • 3000:1 contrast ratio is lower than most TVs.
  • Single-chip DLP may cause rainbow effect.
  • Ambient light reduces image contrast.

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about this comparison

Which projector is brighter for general viewing?

The BenQ W4100i is slightly brighter, rated at 3200 ANSI lumens, compared to the Hisense PX3-PRO's 3000 lumens, offering a marginal advantage in ambient light.

Is the Hisense PX3-PRO better for gaming?

Yes, the Hisense PX3-PRO features a 240Hz high refresh rate and is 'Designed for Xbox,' making it superior for responsive, fluid gaming experiences.

What is the key advantage of the BenQ W4100i's light source?

The BenQ W4100i uses an LED light source with a 10+ year lifespan, ensuring long-term maintenance-free operation and consistent brightness/color without lamp replacements.

Can the Hisense PX3-PRO project a large image without much space?

Absolutely. The Hisense PX3-PRO is an Ultra Short Throw projector, capable of projecting an 80-150 inch image from a very short distance to the screen, ideal for small rooms.

Which projector offers wider color reproduction?

The Hisense PX3-PRO boasts 110% BT.2020 color gamut, which is a wider color space than the BenQ W4100i's 100% DCI-P3, potentially rendering more vibrant colors.

Explore Other Categories

Popular comparisons across the site

Ask AI

Get instant answers about specs

Get the Deets

Ask our AI assistant

Ask Deets anything!