Our Verdict
Electactic Espresso Machine Wins
At a slightly lower price point of $294.79, the Electactic offers superior extraction capabilities with its 20-BAR pump compared to Amaste's 15-BAR pump, alongside a professional-standard 58mm portafilter for better puck preparation and accessory compatibility, against Amaste's limiting 51mm. It also features 30 grind settings for greater precision and a larger 77oz water tank. The Amaste might be a better pick for those prioritizing a slightly smaller footprint, although its specifications are generally less competitive.
Bottom Line: Electactic Espresso Machine is the better choice. At a slightly lower price point of $294.
In-Depth Analysis
How they compare in practice
The Amaste and Electactic espresso machines both aim to bring café-style beverages into the home, each featuring an integrated conical burr grinder and a steam wand. However, their approaches to critical espresso-making specifications lead to distinct real-world performance differences. The most significant divergence lies in the portafilter size and pump pressure. The Electactic boasts a 58mm portafilter, which is the professional standard, offering users a vast ecosystem of accessories for tamping, distribution, and basket upgrades. This also generally allows for a larger coffee dose and more consistent extraction. In contrast, the Amaste's 51mm portafilter, while functional, limits accessory choice and can make achieving optimal puck preparation more challenging for some users. Furthermore, the Electactic's 20-BAR pump capacity surpasses Amaste's 15-BAR, indicating a more robust pressure system, potentially translating to better consistency across various grind settings and coffee types, even though the ideal brewing pressure is typically around 9 BAR. Grind control is another differentiator. The Electactic provides 30 grind settings, offering finer adjustment over coffee particle size, which is crucial for dialing in the perfect shot. Amaste's 15 grind settings offer a decent range but lack the granular precision that more discerning users might appreciate. Both machines utilize a thermoblock boiler, meaning neither will offer the precise temperature stability of a PID-controlled system or a dual-boiler setup, requiring users to manage temperature surfing for optimal results. In terms of convenience, Electactic pulls ahead with a larger 77oz water reservoir compared to Amaste's 68oz, reducing the frequency of refills, especially for households with multiple coffee drinkers. The Electactic also offers adjustable grind time and shot volume, features missing from the Amaste, enhancing repeatability. While the Electactic does have a slightly larger footprint (13.03"W x 11.5"D x 16.1"H), its enhanced features and more competitive pricing at $294.79 versus Amaste's $319.99 make it a compelling value proposition for those seeking greater control and future-proofing in their home espresso setup.
Key Differences
The most significant spec differences at a glance
Pump Pressure
25% lessPortafilter Size
12% lessWater Reservoir
13% lessAdvantages
Where each product wins
Electactic
- Pump Pressure: 25% higher (15 vs 20)
- Portafilter Size: 12% higher (51 vs 58)
- Water Reservoir: 13% higher (68 vs 77.7722)
Which to Pick for Your Situation
Concrete scenarios with a clear recommendation
For the aspiring home barista seeking maximum control and upgrade potential
ElectacticThe Electactic offers a standard 58mm portafilter and 30 grind settings, providing superior precision and access to a wider range of accessories for advanced users.
For a budget-conscious buyer wanting an all-in-one machine
ElectacticPriced lower at $294.79, the Electactic still delivers a 20-BAR pump and integrated grinder, offering better value without compromising key features.
For frequent coffee drinkers in a busy household
ElectacticWith a larger 77.77oz water tank compared to Amaste's 68oz, the Electactic requires fewer refills, ensuring continuous operation.
For users with limited counter space
AmasteWhile specific dimensions aren't provided for Amaste, its lack of a "large footprint" con suggests it's likely more compact than Electactic (13.03"W x 11.5"D x 16.1"H).
Who Should Buy Which?
Find the right product for your needs
Buy Amaste if...
Amaste Espresso Machine with
The Amaste Espresso Machine is ideally suited for the home user making their first foray into integrated espresso systems, prioritizing convenience and a decent entry-level experience without excessive fuss. This buyer values the simplicity of an all-in-one unit, where the integrated conical burr grinder means one less appliance to purchase and manage, making their morning routine smoother. They appreciate the 15-bar pump pressure and low-pressure pre-infusion feature, which together promise a respectable espresso extraction, even if they aren't looking to delve deep into advanced barista techniques. The 68oz water tank is ample for a single user or a couple, reducing frequent refills. This buyer might have a slightly smaller kitchen counter, valuing a machine that integrates neatly, and isn't overly concerned with the professional standard of a 58mm portafilter, being content with the included 51mm accessories. They are not chasing the ultimate customization or a vast ecosystem of third-party tools, preferring a straightforward machine that consistently delivers an enjoyable espresso, latte, or cappuccino. While they forgo the Electactic's higher grind settings and larger portafilter, they gain a potentially more compact design and a reliable, albeit simpler, espresso journey. Their budget is around $320, and they seek a complete solution right out of the box.
Buy Electactic if...
Espresso Machine with Grinder,
The Electactic Espresso Machine caters to the discerning home barista who demands greater control, robust performance, and long-term versatility, all while being mindful of their budget. This buyer is keen on perfecting their espresso craft, making the 58mm portafilter a critical feature; it’s the professional standard, opening up a world of accessories for precise tamping, distribution, and basket upgrades, which significantly impacts extraction quality. They will appreciate the Electactic’s 20-BAR pump, which, while not directly tied to brewing pressure, signifies a powerful and durable system capable of consistent extractions. The 30 integrated grind settings are a major draw for this user, enabling them to finely tune their grind for different beans and desired shot profiles, a level of precision not offered by lesser machines. They also value the convenience of the large 77oz removable water tank, minimizing interruptions during their espresso-making sessions. Features like adjustable grind time and shot volume control empower them to achieve repeatable results and experiment with different recipes. While the Electactic has a slightly larger footprint (13.03"W x 11.5"D x 16.1"H), this buyer is willing to allocate the counter space for a machine that delivers superior functionality and a more professional-grade experience. They are looking for an exceptional value proposition at under $300, understanding that they are getting a machine with advanced features that typically cost more.
Spec Comparison
9 specs compared
| Specification | ![]() | ![]() |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $320 | $295 |
| Rating | 4.1(158) | 4.1(986) |
| Boiler Type | Thermoblock | thermoblock |
| Pump Pressure Bars | 15 | 20 |
| Portafilter Size mm | 51 | 58 |
| Steam Wand | Yes | Yes |
| Model Number | AC-517EA | — |
| Grinder Included | Yes | Yes |
| Water Reservoir oz | 68 | 77.77 |
| Weight | — | 18.04 lbs |
| Dimensions | — | 13.03" × 16.1" × 11.5" |
Swipe horizontally to see all columns
Pros & Cons
Quick overview of strengths and weaknesses
Amaste Espresso Machine
- Integrated conical burr grinder
- 15 grind settings for customization
- 15-bar pump with visual pressure gauge
- Low-pressure pre-infusion feature
- 51mm portafilter limits accessory choice
- Lacks PID for precise temperature control
Electactic Espresso Machine
- 20-BAR pump delivers strong extraction pressure.
- Integrated conical burr grinder included.
- 30 grind settings provide precise control.
- 77 oz removable water tank simplifies refills.
- Thermoblock boiler limits temperature control.
- Large footprint at 13"W x 11.5"D x 16"H.
Frequently Asked Questions
Common questions about this comparison
Which machine offers more precise grind control?
The Electactic machine provides 30 grind settings, offering significantly more granular control over coffee particle size compared to the Amaste's 15 settings.
Is the 58mm portafilter on the Electactic a significant advantage?
Yes, a 58mm portafilter is the industry standard, allowing for better coffee dose, easier puck preparation, and access to a much wider array of third-party accessories.
How often will I need to refill the water tank on each machine?
The Electactic has a 77.77oz water tank, meaning fewer refills than the Amaste's 68oz tank, especially beneficial for multiple daily drinks.
Do either of these machines have PID for temperature control?
No, both the Amaste and Electactic machines utilize a thermoblock boiler, which provides faster heat-up but lacks the precise temperature stability of a PID system.
What is the benefit of the Electactic's 20-BAR pump over Amaste's 15-BAR?
While optimal brewing is around 9 BAR, a 20-BAR pump capacity suggests more robust components and potentially better consistency and extraction power, especially with varying grind sizes.
Explore Other Categories
Popular comparisons across the site
Ask AI
Get instant answers about specs
Get the Deets
Ask our AI assistant
Ask Deets anything!





























