Our Verdict
Alen Alen Air Purifier BreatheSmart 45i Wins

The Alen 45i delivers vastly superior air purification with a CADR smoke rating of 253.33, more than three times higher than the Dyson Purifier Cool PC1's 76 CADR. This makes it far more effective at quickly removing airborne pollutants for a room coverage of around 400 sq ft, despite its slightly higher price of $479.0 versus Dyson's $453.86. The Dyson Purifier Cool PC1 is the better pick if integrated cooling and advanced smart home connectivity via Wi-Fi and app control are higher priorities than rapid air purification.
Bottom Line: Alen Alen Air Purifier BreatheSmart 45i is the better choice. The Alen 45i delivers vastly superior air purification with a CADR smoke rating of 253.
In-Depth Analysis
How they compare in practice
The Alen BreatheSmart 45i and Dyson Purifier Cool PC1 approach home air quality from distinct angles, leading to significant real-world performance differences. The Alen 45i is a dedicated air purification powerhouse, evident in its impressive CADR smoke rating of 253.33. This means it can clean a room of approximately 400 sq ft much faster and more efficiently of smoke and other fine particles compared to the Dyson's modest 76 CADR for a similar coverage area. In a home with chronic allergies, pet dander, or occasional cooking smoke, the Alen will noticeably improve air quality quicker, requiring less extended operation. Its medical-grade HEPA filter also boasts capture down to 0.1 microns, offering a slight edge over Dyson's 0.3-micron capture, crucial for the most sensitive individuals.
Conversely, the Dyson Purifier Cool PC1, while an air purifier, also prominently functions as a high-velocity tower fan, projecting 76 gallons/sec of airflow. This dual functionality is a major draw, providing both cooling and air purification in one sleek, bladeless unit. Its advanced smart features, including Wi-Fi connectivity, app control, voice control, and remote air quality monitoring, offer a more integrated smart home experience. For users prioritizing convenience, precise control, and the added benefit of a powerful fan, the Dyson presents a compelling, albeit less potent in purification-only terms, package.
The trade-off is clear: pure, rapid air purification versus a multi-functional device with smart home integration. The Alen's "ultra-quiet operation" and SmartSensor for auto-adjusting fan speed make it ideal for bedrooms, focusing solely on unobtrusive air cleaning. The Dyson, with its striking design and cooling capabilities, might be better suited for living areas where both air quality and ambient comfort are desired, and where its lower CADR can still be effective with longer run times. Given their similar effective coverage areas (395.83 sq ft for Alen, 400 sq ft for Dyson) and comparable prices, the decision hinges on whether raw purification power and quiet operation or smart features and active cooling are paramount.
Key Differences
The most significant spec differences at a glance
Cadr Smoke
233% moreCoverage Sq Ft
1% lessAdvantages
Where each product wins
Alen
- Cadr Smoke: 233% higher (253.33 vs 76)
Dyson
- Coverage Sq Ft: 1% higher (395.83 vs 400)
Which to Pick for Your Situation
Concrete scenarios with a clear recommendation
For quickly clearing smoke, pet dander, or strong cooking odors in a living room
AlenThe Alen 45i has a significantly higher CADR smoke rating of 253.33, ensuring much faster and more effective removal of airborne pollutants compared to Dyson's 76 CADR.
For a bedroom where quiet operation and fresh air for sleep are priorities
AlenThe Alen 45i is praised for its ultra-quiet operation and SmartSensor, making it ideal for unobtrusive air purification during sleep.
For a modern home desiring integrated cooling, smart home control, and air purification
DysonThe Dyson Purifier Cool PC1 offers 350° oscillation, projects 76 gallons/sec airflow for cooling, and features Wi-Fi, app, and voice control for seamless integration.
For those on a tighter budget but still needing effective purification
DysonThe Dyson is slightly more affordable at $453.86 compared to Alen's $479.0, offering good value for its dual functionality.
Who Should Buy Which?
Find the right product for your needs
Buy Alen if...
Alen Air Purifier BreatheSmart
The ideal buyer for the Alen BreatheSmart 45i is someone whose primary need is uncompromising, fast, and quiet air purification. This individual may suffer from severe allergies, have pets that shed dander, or live in an environment prone to airborne irritants like smoke or pollen. Their priority is truly clean air without distraction, valuing the Alen's high CADR smoke rating of 253.33 which ensures rapid contaminant removal across its 395.83 sq ft effective coverage. They appreciate the medical-grade HEPA Odor Filter's ability to capture particles as small as 0.1 microns and neutralize strong household odors effectively. This buyer isn't necessarily looking for a multi-functional gadget; instead, they want a dedicated, "set it and forget it" air cleaner with an Ultra-quiet operation that won't disrupt their sleep or daily activities. While the price of $479.0 is a consideration, they see it as an investment in superior air quality and health benefits, willingly foregoing the smart home bells and whistles offered by competitors for peak purification performance.
Buy Dyson if...
Dyson Purifier Cool PC1,
The ideal buyer for the Dyson Purifier Cool PC1 is a tech-savvy individual looking for a multi-functional device that seamlessly integrates into their smart home ecosystem while addressing general air quality and comfort. They prioritize design, convenience, and the dual benefit of a powerful fan with air purification, especially in warmer climates or rooms lacking adequate air circulation. This buyer values the Dyson's Wi-Fi enabled app control, voice command capabilities, and remote air quality monitoring, allowing them to manage their environment from anywhere. While they appreciate the HEPA H13 filtration for capturing particles down to 0.3 microns and activated carbon for odors, the lower CADR smoke rating of 76 for its 400 sq ft coverage is an acceptable trade-off for the cooling function that projects 76 gallons/sec of airflow. At a slightly more attractive price point of $453.86, they are willing to accept slightly less raw purification speed for a device that offers both aesthetic appeal and enhanced smart features, serving more than just one purpose in their modern living space.
Spec Comparison
6 specs compared
| Specification | ![]() | ![]() |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $479 | $454 |
| Rating | 4.7(754) | 4.4(141) |
| Cadr Smoke | 253.33 | 76 |
| Coverage Sq Ft | 395.83 | 400 |
| Filter Type | HEPA Odor Filter | HEPA H13 |
| Smart Sensor | Yes | Yes |
| Model Number | — | TP11 |
| WiFi | — | Yes |
Swipe horizontally to see all columns
Pros & Cons
Quick overview of strengths and weaknesses
Alen Air Purifier
- Neutralizes strong household odors
- Medical-grade filter captures 0.1 micron particles
- SmartSensor auto-adjusts fan speed
- High CADR smoke rating (253.33)
- Effective coverage (395 sq ft) less than advertised
- Pink noise feature may not be preferred by all users
- Requires periodic filter replacement
Dyson Purifier Cool
- Captures 99.97% particles down to 0.3 microns.
- Activated carbon filter removes gases and odors.
- HEPA H13 fully sealed filtration system.
- Projects 76 gallons/sec airflow for cooling.
- Low smoke CADR of 76 for 400 sq ft coverage.
- Requires extended operation for full room purification.
Frequently Asked Questions
Common questions about this comparison
Which purifier is better for removing smoke quickly?
The Alen BreatheSmart 45i is significantly better for smoke removal, boasting a CADR smoke rating of 253.33, which is over three times higher than the Dyson Purifier Cool PC1's 76 CADR.
Do both purifiers cover a large room?
Both are effective for rooms around 400 sq ft. The Alen covers 395.83 sq ft effectively, and the Dyson covers 400 sq ft.
Does the Dyson Purifier Cool PC1 also cool the room?
Yes, the Dyson Purifier Cool PC1 functions as a tower fan, projecting 76 gallons/sec of airflow to provide a cooling effect along with air purification.
What kind of particles can each filter capture?
The Alen 45i captures 0.1 micron particles with its medical-grade HEPA filter. The Dyson PC1 captures 99.97% of particles down to 0.3 microns using its HEPA H13 sealed system.
Is there a significant price difference between the two?
The Dyson Purifier Cool PC1 is slightly less expensive at $453.86, while the Alen BreatheSmart 45i is priced at $479.0.
Which unit offers more advanced smart features?
The Dyson Purifier Cool PC1 offers more advanced smart features, including Wi-Fi connectivity, app control, voice control, and remote air quality monitoring, beyond just a smart sensor.
Explore Other Categories
Popular comparisons across the site
Ask AI
Get instant answers about specs
Get the Deets
Ask our AI assistant
Ask Deets anything!



























