Our Verdict
BIG HORN OUTDOORS 16" Woodfire Pizza Stone Oven Wins

This oven achieves a much higher maximum temperature of 1112°F compared to the Ninja's 700°F, allowing for authentic 60-second Neapolitan-style pizzas up to 16 inches. It also heats up faster in 15 minutes and is more affordable at $229.99. The Ninja Woodfire is the better pick for those prioritizing multi-functionality and electric power convenience, capable of roasting and smoking beyond just pizza, albeit for smaller 12-inch pies.
Bottom Line: BIG HORN OUTDOORS 16" Woodfire Pizza Stone Oven is the better choice. This oven achieves a much higher maximum temperature of 1112°F compared to the Ninja's 700°F, allowing for authentic 60-second Neapolitan-style pizzas up to 16 inches.
In-Depth Analysis
How they compare in practice
The BIG HORN OUTDOORS 16" Woodfire Pizza Stone Oven and the Ninja Woodfire Outdoor Pizza Oven represent distinct approaches to outdoor cooking. The Big Horn is a dedicated, high-performance pizza machine, prioritizing authentic wood-fired results. Its standout feature is its ability to reach an astounding 1112°F, significantly hotter than the Ninja's 700°F. This extreme heat is crucial for achieving a true Neapolitan-style pizza with a perfectly charred, crispy crust and airy interior in as little as 60-90 seconds. The larger 16-inch cooking surface also caters to those who prefer bigger pizzas, perfect for feeding a crowd.
In contrast, the Ninja Woodfire Outdoor Pizza Oven leans heavily into versatility, offering 8 distinct cooking functions beyond pizza, including roasting, baking, and smoking. While its 700°F maximum temperature is still excellent for pizza, it doesn't match the Big Horn's intensity, leading to a longer 3-minute cook time for its smaller 12-inch pizzas. The Ninja's multi-fuel system, combining electric power for heat with wood pellets for smoke, offers a significant convenience advantage; it plugs in, eliminating the need to manage a live wood pellet fire for primary heating. This makes it a more accessible option for casual backyard chefs who want a broad range of outdoor cooking options with minimal fuss, accepting the trade-off of slightly less authentic pizza performance.
The preheating times further highlight their differences. The Big Horn, despite reaching a much higher temperature, is ready in 15 minutes, while the Ninja requires 25 minutes. This faster turnaround, combined with the quick cooking, makes the Big Horn more efficient for churning out multiple pizzas. However, the Big Horn's reliance solely on wood pellets means a commitment to managing that fuel source, whereas the Ninja's electric power ensures consistent heat. The Big Horn, weighing 42 lbs and having larger dimensions (25"D x 18"W x 36"H including chimney), is less portable than the unspecified but clearly more compact Ninja, which aims for easy relocation with its "portable" designation. Ultimately, the Big Horn offers a purist, high-heat pizza experience at a lower price point ($229.99 vs $279.95), while the Ninja provides a broader, more convenient outdoor cooking ecosystem.
Key Differences
The most significant spec differences at a glance
Max Temp F
59% moreCooking Surface Inches
33% moreHeat Up Time Minutes
40% lessCook Time Seconds
67% lessPizza Size Inches
33% moreAdvantages
Where each product wins
BIG HORN OUTDOORS
- Max Temp F: 59% higher (1112.0 vs 700.0)
- Cooking Surface Inches: 33% higher (16.0 vs 12.0)
- Pizza Size Inches: 33% higher (16.0 vs 12.0)
Ninja
- Heat Up Time Minutes: 40% higher (15.0 vs 25.0)
- Cook Time Seconds: 67% higher (60.0 vs 180.0)
Which to Pick for Your Situation
Concrete scenarios with a clear recommendation
For the authentic Neapolitan pizza enthusiast
BIG HORN OUTDOORSThe BIG HORN OUTDOORS oven reaches 1112°F, delivering genuine 60-second Neapolitan pizzas on a 16-inch stone, unmatched by the Ninja's 700°F.
For diverse outdoor cooking needs beyond just pizza
NinjaThe Ninja Woodfire is an 8-in-1 appliance, offering roasting, smoking, and more, making it ideal for versatile backyard chefs, whereas the Big Horn is pizza-specific.
For maximum pizza size and speed
BIG HORN OUTDOORSWith a 16-inch cooking surface and 60-second cook times, the Big Horn churns out larger pizzas much faster than the Ninja's 12-inch, 3-minute pizzas.
For convenient, electric-powered operation
NinjaThe Ninja operates on consistent electrical power with optional wood pellets for flavor, simplifying fuel management compared to the Big Horn's wood pellet-only heating.
Who Should Buy Which?
Find the right product for your needs
Buy BIG HORN OUTDOORS if...
BIG HORN OUTDOORS 16"
The ideal buyer for the BIG HORN OUTDOORS 16" Woodfire Pizza Stone Oven is a dedicated pizza enthusiast or someone who frequently hosts outdoor gatherings and wants to impress with truly authentic, fast-cooked pizzas. They prioritize achieving a high-quality, Neapolitan-style crust above all else, appreciating the specific nuances of wood-fired cooking. This buyer isn't deterred by managing wood pellet fuel and is willing to invest a little more time in understanding temperature distribution for perfect results. Their priority specs are the oven's exceptional max temperature of 1112°F and the generous 16-inch cooking surface, which allows for larger pies that cook in a mere 60-90 seconds. While the 42lb weight makes it less nimble, they value the robust construction and the capability to consistently produce professional-grade pizzas. They might have a dedicated outdoor kitchen space or a patio where the oven can reside, or they plan for slightly less frequent transport. They understand that by choosing this dedicated pizza oven, they are foregoing the multi-functionality of an appliance like the Ninja, but they are gaining unparalleled pizza performance at a competitive price of $229.99.
Buy Ninja if...
Ninja Woodfire Outdoor Pizza
The Ninja Woodfire Outdoor Pizza Oven is perfect for the versatile backyard chef who desires convenience and multi-functionality in a single outdoor appliance. This buyer wants to do more than just pizza; they envision roasting a chicken, baking bread, or adding authentic smoky flavor to various dishes, making full use of its 8-in-1 capabilities. They appreciate the ease of electric operation, even if it means needing a power outlet, as it simplifies setup and temperature control, eliminating the need to constantly monitor a live flame. The 700°F maximum temperature is perfectly adequate for delicious 12-inch pizzas that cook in about 3 minutes without turning, and the integrated BBQ smoker box is a huge draw for adding wood-fired taste without the full commitment of a traditional smoker. While they might pay slightly more at $279.95 and sacrifice the extreme heat and larger pizza size of a dedicated wood-fired oven, they gain immense flexibility, a shorter learning curve, and the ability to cook a wide array of meals outdoors with minimal fuss. This buyer values a streamlined cooking experience and broad utility over highly specialized performance in one specific area.
Spec Comparison
11 specs compared
| Specification | ![]() | ![]() |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $230 | $280 |
| Rating | 4.3(164) | 4.5(785) |
| Max Temp F | 1112 | 700 |
| Fuel Type | Wood Pellets | Multi-Fuel |
| Cooking Surface Inches | 16" | 12" |
| Heat Up Time Minutes | 15 min | 25 min |
| Portable | Yes | Yes |
| Model Number | SRPG23001 | OO101 |
| Chimney Included | Yes | — |
| Cook Time Seconds | 60 | 180 |
| Dimensions | 18" × 36" × 25" | — |
| Pizza Size Inches | 16" | 12" |
| Built In Thermometer | Yes | — |
Swipe horizontally to see all columns
Pros & Cons
Quick overview of strengths and weaknesses
BIG HORN OUTDOORS 16" Woodfire
- Attains 1112°F operating temperature.
- Cooks 16-inch pizza in 60-90 seconds.
- Preheats to 300°C in 15 minutes.
- Integrated thermometer for temp observation.
- 42lb weight may limit easy transport.
- Requires specific hardwood fuel.
- Temperature distribution may require manual adjustment.
- Initial 15-minute preheat required.
Ninja Woodfire Outdoor
- Achieves 700°F for rapid cooking and charring.
- Cooks 12-inch pizzas in 3 minutes without turning.
- Supports 8 distinct cooking functions outdoors.
- Accommodates large items: 12lb turkey, 9lb pork.
- Requires a 25-minute preheat before use.
- Operation requires consistent electrical power.
- Needs additional cover for full weather protection.
Frequently Asked Questions
Common questions about this comparison
What is the maximum temperature reached by the BIG HORN OUTDOORS pizza oven?
The BIG HORN OUTDOORS 16" Woodfire Pizza Stone Oven can attain an impressive maximum temperature of 1112°F, allowing for extremely fast, high-heat cooking.
How quickly can the Ninja Woodfire Outdoor Pizza Oven cook a pizza?
The Ninja Woodfire can cook a 12-inch pizza in approximately 3 minutes, achieving a good char and rapid cooking at its 700°F maximum temperature.
What are the main fuel types for each oven?
The BIG HORN OUTDOORS oven exclusively uses wood pellets for fuel. The Ninja Woodfire is multi-fuel, using electric power for primary heat and wood pellets for added smoke flavor.
Which oven heats up faster?
The BIG HORN OUTDOORS oven heats up faster, reaching operating temperature in just 15 minutes. The Ninja Woodfire requires a longer 25-minute preheat time.
Can the Ninja Woodfire oven cook items other than pizza?
Yes, the Ninja Woodfire is an 8-in-1 appliance, capable of roasting, baking, smoking, and more. It can accommodate large items like a 12lb turkey.
What is the size difference in pizzas these ovens can make?
The BIG HORN OUTDOORS oven can cook larger 16-inch pizzas, while the Ninja Woodfire is designed for 12-inch pizzas.
Explore Other Categories
Popular comparisons across the site
Ask AI
Get instant answers about specs
Get the Deets
Ask our AI assistant
Ask Deets anything!






















