Bertello SimulFIRE Outdoor Pizza Oven Bundle - Wood Fire Portable 12 inch Brick Oven with Gas Burner, Peel, Wood Tray, Cover, & Thermometer - Portable Pizza Maker - As Seen on SHARK TANK - Portable Pizza Ovens
72

Bertello

SimulFIRE Bundle Fire

4.2
$400
Check Price on Amazon
VS
Solo Stove Pi Prime Pizza Oven Outdoor - Gas Pizza Oven Propane - Portable with Cordierite Stone Cooking Surface - Demi-Dome Design - Wide-Mouthed Opening - Stainless Steel - Portable Pizza Ovens
74

Solo Stove

Pi Prime Propane

4.6
$340
Check Price on Amazon

Our Verdict

Solo Stove Pi Prime Wins

Solo Stove Pi Prime Pizza Oven Outdoor - Gas Pizza Oven Propane - Portable with Cordierite Stone Cooking Surface - Demi-Dome Design - Wide-Mouthed Opening - Stainless Steel - Portable Pizza Ovens

While Bertello offers multi-fuel capability, the Solo Stove Pi Prime wins on value and speed, heating to 900F in just 15 minutes compared to Bertello's 20 minutes, and cooking a pizza in 90 seconds, all at a lower price point of $339.99 versus $399.99. The Bertello is the better pick for those prioritizing authentic wood-fired flavor combined with the convenience of gas, or those who value its robust 15.24mm stone and included accessories.

Bottom Line: Solo Stove Pi Prime is the better choice. While Bertello offers multi-fuel capability, the Solo Stove Pi Prime wins on value and speed, heating to 900F in just 15 minutes compared to Bertello's 20 minutes, and cooking a pizza in 90 seconds, all at a lower price point of $339.

In-Depth Analysis

How they compare in practice

The Bertello SimulFIRE and Solo Stove Pi Prime both target the 12-inch portable outdoor pizza oven market, but diverge significantly in their approach to fuel and user experience. The most prominent difference lies in their fuel types: Bertello offers a unique multi-fuel system, allowing simultaneous use of gas and wood for enhanced flavor, a feature the propane-only Solo Stove Pi Prime cannot match. This multi-fuel capability, coupled with Bertello's HeatTrap design and a substantial 15.24mm removable stone, suggests a more versatile cooking experience, potentially offering a truer 'brick oven' taste profile for those willing to manage wood and ash. However, this comes at a higher price of $399.99 and a slightly longer heat-up time of 20 minutes to reach its 900F maximum temperature. Its robust bundle with a peel, wood tray, cover, and thermometer adds value, making it a more complete package out of the box.

Conversely, the Solo Stove Pi Prime prioritizes speed, simplicity, and a lower entry price. At $339.99, it heats up to 900F in a swift 15 minutes and boasts a remarkable 90-second cook time per pizza. Its propane-only operation streamlines setup and cleanup, appealing to users who want minimal fuss. The wide-mouthed opening facilitates easy pizza handling, a practical design choice for rapid-fire cooking. While it lacks the wood-fire option for flavor complexity, its Cordierite stone surface still ensures a crispy crust. The trade-off is between the Solo Stove's sheer efficiency and convenience versus the Bertello's more traditional, flavor-rich, yet slightly more involved, multi-fuel cooking method.

Key Differences

The most significant spec differences at a glance

20

Heat Up Time Minutes

33% more
15

Advantages

Where each product wins

Bertello SimulFIRE Outdoor Pizza Oven Bundle - Wood Fire Portable 12 inch Brick Oven with Gas Burner, Peel, Wood Tray, Cover, & Thermometer - Portable Pizza Maker - As Seen on SHARK TANK - Portable Pizza Ovens

Bertello

  • Heat Up Time Minutes: 33% higher (20 vs 15)

Which to Pick for Your Situation

Concrete scenarios with a clear recommendation

For the fastest pizza night

Solo Stove

The Solo Stove Pi Prime heats up in 15 minutes and cooks a pizza in 90 seconds, making it ideal for quick meals.

For authentic wood-fired flavor

Bertello

The Bertello SimulFIRE supports simultaneous gas and wood use, allowing for a more authentic, smoky pizza taste that the Solo Stove cannot replicate.

For budget-conscious buyers

Solo Stove

The Solo Stove Pi Prime is more affordable at $339.99, compared to the Bertello's $399.99 price tag.

For ease of cleaning and minimal fuss

Solo Stove

As a propane-only oven, the Solo Stove Pi Prime avoids the ash cleanup associated with wood burning, simplifying maintenance.

Who Should Buy Which?

Find the right product for your needs

Bertello SimulFIRE Outdoor Pizza Oven Bundle - Wood Fire Portable 12 inch Brick Oven with Gas Burner, Peel, Wood Tray, Cover, & Thermometer - Portable Pizza Maker - As Seen on SHARK TANK - Portable Pizza Ovens

Buy Bertello if...

Bertello SimulFIRE Outdoor Pizza

The ideal buyer for the Bertello SimulFIRE Outdoor Pizza Oven Bundle is someone who craves the authentic taste of wood-fired pizza but also values the convenience and consistent heat of gas. This individual is likely an enthusiast who enjoys experimenting with flavor profiles, appreciating the ability to use wood and gas simultaneously to achieve a unique smoky crust. They don't mind the slightly longer 20-minute heat-up time to 900F or the minor effort of ash cleanup, as the superior taste justifies it. This buyer also benefits from the robust build, including a thick 15.24mm removable stone for excellent heat retention, and the comprehensive bundle that includes essential accessories like a peel, wood tray, cover, and thermometer, making the $399.99 price a worthwhile investment for a complete, versatile pizza-making setup. They are willing to trade a few minutes of heat-up time for the unparalleled flexibility in fuel and flavor.

Solo Stove Pi Prime Pizza Oven Outdoor - Gas Pizza Oven Propane - Portable with Cordierite Stone Cooking Surface - Demi-Dome Design - Wide-Mouthed Opening - Stainless Steel - Portable Pizza Ovens

Buy Solo Stove if...

Solo Stove Pi Prime

The Solo Stove Pi Prime Outdoor Pizza Oven is perfect for the user who prioritizes speed, simplicity, and efficiency above all else. This buyer wants to make delicious homemade pizzas quickly and effortlessly, valuing the oven's ability to reach 900F in just 15 minutes and cook a 12-inch pizza in an impressive 90 seconds. They appreciate the straightforward propane-only operation, which means easy setup, consistent heat, and minimal cleanup compared to wood-fired options. Cost-effectiveness is also a factor, with the Pi Prime's $339.99 price point offering great value for its performance. This user may live in an apartment or have limited outdoor space, making the portable, compact design and clean fuel source particularly appealing. They are content with delicious gas-fired pizza and don't require the added complexity or nuanced flavor of wood burning, seeking a hassle-free, high-performance cooking experience.

Spec Comparison

10 specs compared

Specification
Bertello SimulFIRE Outdoor Pizza Oven Bundle - Wood Fire Portable 12 inch Brick Oven with Gas Burner, Peel, Wood Tray, Cover, & Thermometer - Portable Pizza Maker - As Seen on SHARK TANK - Portable Pizza Ovens
Bertello SimulFIRE Outdoor Pizza
Solo Stove Pi Prime Pizza Oven Outdoor - Gas Pizza Oven Propane - Portable with Cordierite Stone Cooking Surface - Demi-Dome Design - Wide-Mouthed Opening - Stainless Steel - Portable Pizza Ovens
Solo Stove Pi Prime Pizza
Price$400$340
Rating4.2(533)4.6(215)
Max Temp F900900
Fuel TypeMulti-FuelPropane Only
Cooking Surface Inches12"12"
Heat Up Time Minutes20 min15 min
Stone Thickness mm15.24
PortableYesYes
Model NumberSKUOVENEVERY2PRIME-20
Pizza Size Inches12"
Built In ThermometerYes
Cook Time Seconds90

Swipe horizontally to see all columns

Pros & Cons

Quick overview of strengths and weaknesses

Bertello SimulFIRE Outdoor Pizza Oven Bundle - Wood Fire Portable 12 inch Brick Oven with Gas Burner, Peel, Wood Tray, Cover, & Thermometer - Portable Pizza Maker - As Seen on SHARK TANK

Bertello SimulFIRE Outdoor

Pros
  • Simultaneous gas & wood use for flavor.
  • Reaches 900F in under 20 minutes for fast cook.
  • HeatTrap design distributes heat evenly.
  • Removable 15.24mm stone simplifies cleaning.
Cons
  • Limited to 12-inch pizza size.
  • Requires gas connection for optimal heating.
  • Wood burning adds ash cleanup requirement.
  • Outdoor-only operation limits use location.
Solo Stove Pi Prime Pizza Oven Outdoor - Gas Pizza Oven Propane - Portable with Cordierite Stone Cooking Surface - Demi-Dome Design - Wide-Mouthed Opening - Stainless Steel

Solo Stove Pi Prime

Pros
  • Heats to 900F in 15 minutes.
  • Cooks one pizza in 90 seconds.
  • Propane fuel offers outdoor portability.
  • Wide opening allows easy pizza handling.
Cons
  • Limited to 12-inch pizza size.
  • Requires propane fuel only.
  • No wood fire fuel option available.

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about this comparison

What is the maximum temperature these ovens can reach?

Both the Bertello SimulFIRE and Solo Stove Pi Prime can reach a maximum temperature of 900F, essential for achieving Neapolitan-style pizzas.

How quickly do these pizza ovens heat up?

The Solo Stove Pi Prime heats up faster, reaching 900F in 15 minutes. The Bertello SimulFIRE takes slightly longer, achieving 900F in under 20 minutes.

Can I use wood and gas simultaneously with these ovens?

Only the Bertello SimulFIRE supports simultaneous gas and wood fuel types for enhanced flavor. The Solo Stove Pi Prime is propane-only.

What size pizzas can these ovens cook?

Both ovens are designed to cook pizzas up to 12 inches in diameter, suitable for personal or small-group servings.

Does either oven come with a built-in thermometer?

The Bertello SimulFIRE Outdoor Pizza Oven Bundle includes a built-in thermometer, providing convenient temperature monitoring. The Solo Stove Pi Prime does not specify a built-in thermometer.

Explore Other Categories

Popular comparisons across the site

Ask AI

Get instant answers about specs

Get the Deets

Ask our AI assistant

Ask Deets anything!