Our Verdict
Breville Barista Express Espresso Machine BES870XL Wins
In-Depth Analysis
How they compare in practice
The Breville Barista Express and Gaggia Classic Evo Pro represent distinct philosophies in home espresso. Its integrated burr grinder and 67 oz water reservoir streamline the espresso-making process, saving counter space and simplifying workflow. The thermoblock boiler heats quickly, and PID temperature control ensures stable brew temperatures, a critical factor for consistent shot quality. While its 15-bar pump pressure is higher than ideal for extraction, Breville machines typically employ an over-pressure valve to ensure proper brewing pressure. The 54mm portafilter is proprietary, limiting accessory compatibility compared to commercial standards. Its manual steam wand, though capable, requires practice to master milk texturing. It lacks an integrated grinder, requiring a separate purchase, but offers a commercial-standard 58mm portafilter, which provides excellent thermal mass for stable extraction and allows for widespread accessory upgrades. The Gaggia's consistent 9-bar extraction pressure is often considered the optimal standard for espresso, contributing to a balanced shot. Its single boiler design means you must wait for the boiler to heat or cool between brewing espresso and steaming milk, impacting workflow efficiency for milk-based drinks. However, this design contributes to its robust and repairable nature, with a solid steel housing built for longevity. The Gaggia appeals to those who enjoy the ritual of espresso and may wish to modify their machine over time for enhanced performance.
Key Differences
The most significant spec differences at a glance
Pump Pressure
67% morePortafilter Size
7% lessAdvantages
Where each product wins
Breville
- Pump Pressure: 67% higher (15.0 vs 9.0)
Gaggia
- Portafilter Size: 7% higher (54.0 vs 58.0)
Which to Pick for Your Situation
Concrete scenarios with a clear recommendation
For the first-time espresso maker seeking convenience
BrevilleThe Breville Barista Express includes an integrated burr grinder and PID control, providing an all-in-one, ready-to-use system with less guesswork.
For minimal counter space
BrevilleThe Breville Barista Express saves space with its built-in grinder, eliminating the need for a separate appliance.
For quality extraction and future upgradeability
GaggiaThe Gaggia's standard 58mm portafilter and ideal 9-bar pump pressure offer superior extraction potential and compatibility with commercial accessories.
Who Should Buy Which?
Find the right product for your needs
Buy Breville if...
BES870XL
The Breville Barista Express Espresso Machine BES870XL is ideal for the aspiring home barista who values convenience, consistency, and an all-in-one solution. This buyer wants to jump into making quality espresso drinks without the complexity of sourcing multiple pieces of equipment. They appreciate the integrated burr grinder for fresh coffee and the PID temperature control ensuring a stable brew every time. The 67 oz water reservoir means fewer refills, fitting a busy lifestyle. They might not be interested in deep customization or the 'tinkering' aspect that more traditional machines offer, preferring a streamlined experience over a highly modular one. While they may forgo the commercial standard 58mm portafilter, the Breville's convenience and feature set at its price point are paramount to their needs.
Buy Gaggia if...
RI9380/51
The Gaggia Classic Evo Pro Espresso Machine is perfectly suited for the espresso enthusiast or budding prosumer who prioritizes shot quality, durability, and future upgradeability, even if it means a more involved process. They appreciate the Gaggia's robust solid steel housing and its commercial 58mm portafilter, which allows for better thermal stability and compatibility with a vast array of aftermarket accessories and tools. The consistent 9-bar pump pressure is a key draw, appealing to those who understand its importance for optimal extraction. This user enjoys the ritual of espresso making, is patient with the single boiler workflow (waiting between brewing and steaming), and may even look forward to modifying the machine in the future. They value the machine's classic, no-frills design and its reputation for longevity and repairability over integrated smart features.
Spec Comparison
10 specs compared
| Specification | ![]() | ![]() |
|---|---|---|
| Rating | 4.5(27.1k) | 4.1(3.0k) |
| Boiler Type | thermoblock | Single |
| Pump Pressure Bars | 15 | 9 |
| Portafilter Size mm | 54 | 58 |
| Steam Wand | Yes | Yes |
| Weight | 22.1 lbs | — |
| Grinder Included | Yes | — |
| Dimensions | 12.5" × 15.9" × 13.8" | — |
| Water Reservoir oz | 67 | — |
| PID Temperature Control | Yes | — |
| Model Number | — | RI9380/51 |
Swipe horizontally to see all columns
Pros & Cons
Quick overview of strengths and weaknesses
Breville BES870XL
- Integrated burr grinder saves counter space.
- PID control stabilizes brew water temperature.
- Low pressure pre-infusion aids even flavor draw.
- Manual steam wand allows milk texture control.
- 54mm portafilter limits basket compatibility.
- Manual milk texturing requires learned skill.
- Large physical dimensions may consume counter space.
- 22.1 lb weight makes unit less portable.
Gaggia RI9380/51
- Consistent 9-bar extraction pressure.
- Durable solid steel housing.
- Standard 58mm commercial portafilter.
- Commercial three-way valve dries puck.
- Single boiler prevents simultaneous brew/steam.
- Warm-up time required for temperature changes.
Frequently Asked Questions
Common questions about this comparison
Does the Breville Barista Express include a grinder?
Yes, the Breville Barista Express BES870XL features an integrated conical burr grinder, allowing you to grind fresh coffee beans directly into the portafilter.
What is the portafilter size for each machine?
The Breville Barista Express uses a 54mm portafilter, while the Gaggia Classic Evo Pro features a standard commercial 58mm portafilter, offering more accessory options.
Which machine is better for making milk-based drinks like lattes?
Both machines have manual steam wands. The Breville's thermoblock heats faster for steaming, while Gaggia's single boiler requires a temperature change wait after brewing espresso.
What is the key difference in pump pressure?
The Breville Barista Express has a 15-bar pump, typically regulated for brewing. The Gaggia Classic Evo Pro features a consistent 9-bar pump, considered optimal for espresso extraction.
Is the Gaggia Classic Evo Pro suitable for beginners?
While capable, the Gaggia Classic Evo Pro is more hands-on due to its single boiler and lack of an integrated grinder, making it better for those willing to learn.
Explore Other Categories
Popular comparisons across the site
Ask AI
Get instant answers about specs
Get the Deets
Ask our AI assistant
Ask Deets anything!































