Our Verdict
Product B (Alen BreatheSmart 45i HEPA with Pure Filter) Wins

Priced $75 lower at $404.1, it delivers substantially superior performance, boasting a CADR smoke rating of 1216.0 and genuine coverage of up to 1900 sq ft. Product A, despite its marketing, only effectively covers 395.83 sq ft with a much lower CADR of 253.33 for smoke. Product A is the better pick only if you require a highly specialized odor-focused filter for a smaller room and prioritize its specific "Odor Filter" over raw air purification speed.
Bottom Line: Product B (Alen BreatheSmart 45i HEPA with Pure Filter) is the better choice. Priced $75 lower at $404.
In-Depth Analysis
How they compare in practice
The Alen BreatheSmart 45i line presents a fascinating internal comparison, where the "Pure Filter" variant (Product B) decisively outperforms its "Odor Filter" sibling (Product A) in core purification metrics, surprisingly at a lower price point. The most striking difference lies in their effective coverage and CADR smoke ratings. Product B genuinely purifies up to 1900 sq ft, supported by an impressive CADR smoke of 1216.0. This means it can rapidly clear smoke, dust, and other particulates from very large open-plan living areas or quickly refresh the air in smaller spaces multiple times an hour.
In contrast, Product A, despite being marketed for 1900 sq ft, delivers an effective coverage of just 395.83 sq ft and a CADR smoke of 253.33, positioning it firmly for bedrooms or small offices. This disparity fundamentally alters their real-world application. A household dealing with widespread allergens, pet dander, or significant smoke across a large area will find Product B vastly more capable and efficient. Its ability to process air at a much higher volume and speed means a quicker reduction in airborne contaminants.
Product A, on the other hand, with its "HEPA Odor Filter," is designed with a more specialized focus on neutralizing strong household odors. While Product B's higher air turnover will also help with odors, Product A might offer a more targeted chemical absorption for specific smells. The price also weighs heavily, as Product B is priced at $404.1, while Product A costs $479.0. This $75 difference makes Product B an exceptional value proposition, offering significantly more raw purification power and coverage for less money. Both units feature the convenient SmartSensor and operate quietly, emitting pink noise for sleep, ensuring a similar user experience in terms of noise levels and automated operation. However, the trade-off is clear: prioritize broad, rapid air purification and coverage at a better price, or pay more for specialized odor filtration in a smaller footprint.
Key Differences
The most significant spec differences at a glance
Cadr Smoke
79% lessCoverage Sq Ft
79% lessAdvantages
Where each product wins
Alen
- Cadr Smoke: 79% higher (253.33 vs 1216.0)
- Coverage Sq Ft: 79% higher (395.83 vs 1900.0)
Which to Pick for Your Situation
Concrete scenarios with a clear recommendation
For a large open-plan living space
AlenProduct B genuinely covers up to 1900 sq ft with a high CADR of 1216.0 for smoke, making it ideal for large areas.
For targeted odor removal in a bedroom
AlenProduct A features a specialized "HEPA Odor Filter" and its 395.83 sq ft effective coverage is well-suited for smaller, contained spaces.
For households with heavy smoke or allergen issues
AlenProduct B's significantly higher CADR smoke rating of 1216.0 ensures rapid and effective removal of airborne contaminants across a large area.
For a tight budget seeking maximum value
AlenProduct B offers superior coverage and CADR at a lower price point of $404.1 compared to Product A's $479.0.
Who Should Buy Which?
Find the right product for your needs
Buy Alen if...
Alen Air Purifier BreatheSmart
The ideal buyer for the Alen BreatheSmart 45i with Odor Filter (Product A) is someone primarily concerned with persistent, specific household odors in a contained, medium-sized space like a bedroom, nursery, or a dedicated home office. They live in an environment where smells from cooking, pets, or everyday activities are a concern, and they value a specialized solution for neutralizing these, leveraging the unique "HEPA Odor Filter." While they might see the 1900 sq ft advertised coverage, their actual room size aligns perfectly with its effective 395.83 sq ft purification capability. They highly appreciate the ultra-quiet operation and the soothing pink noise feature for an undisturbed sleep or work environment, making it unobtrusive. This buyer is willing to invest a bit more ($479.0) for a filter explicitly designed for targeted odor mitigation and a serene atmosphere, even if it means sacrificing the extensive area coverage or raw CADR power offered by Product B, which they don't necessarily need for their specific, smaller-scale use case. They prioritize a tranquil environment and precise odor control over sheer air volume processing, accepting a lower CADR smoke of 253.33 for this specialized focus.
Buy Alen if...
Alen Air Purifier BreatheSmart
The Alen BreatheSmart 45i with Pure Filter (Product B) is perfectly suited for buyers with large living spaces, open-concept homes, or environments with significant airborne particulate challenges like heavy dust, allergens, or smoke. This individual prioritizes maximum air purification power and extensive coverage across their entire space. They will greatly benefit from its genuine 1900 sq ft coverage and its impressive CADR smoke rating of 1216.0, which ensures rapid and comprehensive air cleaning across a wide area, cycling air quickly and efficiently. This buyer is often budget-conscious but unwilling to compromise on performance, finding Product B's $404.1 price point an exceptional value for its capabilities compared to Product A's higher cost for less coverage. They might have multiple pets, live in a city with poor air quality, or simply want to ensure the entire main living area of their home is consistently purified with superior air turnover. While it also handles odors effectively due to high air processing volume, their primary need is broad, powerful, and cost-effective air filtration, for which Product B is overwhelmingly superior. They are seeking the best performance per dollar for large-scale air purification.
Spec Comparison
4 specs compared
| Specification | ![]() | ![]() |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $479 | $404 |
| Rating | 4.7(754) | 4.7(754) |
| Cadr Smoke | 253.33 | 1216 |
| Coverage Sq Ft | 395.83 | 1900 |
| Filter Type | HEPA Odor Filter | HEPA H13 |
| Smart Sensor | Yes | Yes |
Swipe horizontally to see all columns
Pros & Cons
Quick overview of strengths and weaknesses
Alen Air Purifier
- Neutralizes strong household odors
- Medical-grade filter captures 0.1 micron particles
- SmartSensor auto-adjusts fan speed
- High CADR smoke rating (253.33)
- Effective coverage (395 sq ft) less than advertised
- Pink noise feature may not be preferred by all users
- Requires periodic filter replacement
Alen Air Purifier
- Covers up to 1900 sq ft hourly
- Removes 99.9% of 0.1 micron particles
- SmartSensor auto-adjusts fan speed
- Operates quietly, emits pink noise for sleep
- Requires ongoing purchase of replacement filters
- Unit requires dedicated space due to large coverage
- Operational noise level at max fan speed unknown
Frequently Asked Questions
Common questions about this comparison
What is the actual room coverage for these Alen 45i models?
Product B effectively covers up to 1900 sq ft, while Product A is better suited for rooms up to 395.83 sq ft, despite both being advertised for 1900 sq ft.
Which Alen 45i is better for pet odors?
Product A has a specialized "HEPA Odor Filter" for targeted neutralization. Product B's higher CADR of 1216.0 for smoke also processes air faster, highly effective for general odor removal.
Are these air purifiers quiet enough for sleeping?
Both Alen BreatheSmart 45i models are designed for ultra-quiet operation and emit soothing pink noise, making them suitable for use in bedrooms and promoting sleep.
What's the main difference between their filter types?
Product A uses a "HEPA Odor Filter" for specialized odor neutralization. Product B uses a "HEPA H13" filter, offering broad high-efficiency particulate removal across a larger coverage area.
Does the price difference reflect performance?
Surprisingly, Product B, priced at $404.1, offers superior performance with a CADR smoke of 1216.0 and 1900 sq ft coverage, making it a better value than Product A at $479.0.
Explore Other Categories
Popular comparisons across the site
Ask AI
Get instant answers about specs
Get the Deets
Ask our AI assistant
Ask Deets anything!
























