Breville Barista Express Espresso Machine BES870BTR, Black Truffle - Home Espresso Machines
73

Breville

Barista Express BES870BTR

4.5
$700
Check Price on Amazon
VS
Koolatron Kenmore Espresso Machine - Automatic Coffee Maker With Auto Tamper, Auto Cleaning, Milk Steamer & Frother, Bean Grinder, Make Professional Barista Style Cappuccino, Latte, Stainless Steel - Home Espresso Machines
56

Koolatron

Kenmore Auto Tamper

5.0
$952
Check Price on Amazon

Our Verdict

Breville Barista Express Espresso Machine BES870BTR Wins

Breville Barista Express Espresso Machine BES870BTR, Black Truffle - Home Espresso Machines

Despite both utilizing thermoblock boilers, the Breville offers superior temperature stability with PID control and a remarkably fast 0.5-minute heat-up time, crucial for consistent espresso extraction. This advanced performance comes at a significantly lower price of $699.95 compared to the Kenmore's $951.99. The Kenmore might be the better pick for those prioritizing maximum automation, an optimal 9.0 bar pump without manual intervention, and integrated convenience features, provided its undisclosed portafilter size and potential temperature variability are acceptable trade-offs.

Bottom Line: Breville Barista Express Espresso Machine BES870BTR is the better choice. Despite both utilizing thermoblock boilers, the Breville offers superior temperature stability with PID control and a remarkably fast 0.

In-Depth Analysis

How they compare in practice

The Breville Barista Express BES870BTR and the Koolatron Kenmore Espresso Machine cater to distinct segments of home coffee enthusiasts, differing primarily in their approach to control versus convenience and their overall value proposition. The Breville, priced at $699.95, cultivates a more hands-on barista experience, featuring an integrated grinder with dose control and a manual steam wand. Its PID temperature control is a significant advantage, ensuring the 67.0 oz water reservoir's water is heated consistently for optimal extraction, directly addressing a common thermoblock limitation. The 15-bar pump, combined with low-pressure pre-infusion, aims for a balanced extraction. Users actively engage with grinding directly into the 54.0mm portafilter, tamping (though manual), and milk texturing.

Conversely, the Koolatron Kenmore, at $951.99, positions itself as a fully automatic solution. While it boasts an optimal 9.0 bar pump pressure for extraction, a key selling point is its comprehensive suite of automated features: an integrated bean grinder, an automatic tamper for consistent puck preparation, and a built-in milk steamer and frother, all culminating in an auto-cleaning function. This significantly reduces the manual effort involved, appealing to users who prioritize speed and simplicity over the craft of espresso making. However, the absence of mentioned PID control could mean less temperature stability compared to the Breville, potentially impacting shot quality consistency.

In real-world use, the Breville user embraces the ritual, learning to dial in grind size and tamping pressure for nuanced flavor. The 54mm portafilter, while non-standard, still allows for skilled operation. The 0.5-minute heat-up time means quick readiness for that morning shot. The Koolatron user, on the other hand, values minimal interaction. They push a button and receive a latte, appreciating the consistent 9-bar pressure and automated tamping, even if it means sacrificing granular control and potentially some flavor optimization. The higher price point for the Kenmore reflects this increased automation and convenience. The trade-off is clear: hands-on mastery and temperature precision with Breville versus effortless, consistent output with Kenmore, with the latter costing significantly more without explicit temperature stabilization.

Key Differences

The most significant spec differences at a glance

15

Pump Pressure

67% more
9

Advantages

Where each product wins

Breville Barista Express Espresso Machine BES870BTR, Black Truffle - Home Espresso Machines

Breville

  • Pump Pressure: 67% higher (15.0 vs 9.0)

Which to Pick for Your Situation

Concrete scenarios with a clear recommendation

Aspiring home barista on a budget

Breville

The Breville Barista Express offers PID temperature control and an integrated grinder for $699.95, providing excellent value for learning espresso skills without breaking the bank.

Busy professional seeking maximum convenience

Koolatron

The Koolatron Kenmore's automatic tamper, built-in milk frother, and auto-cleaning functions deliver professional-style beverages with minimal user effort, despite the higher $951.99 price.

User prioritizing precise espresso extraction

Tie

The Breville provides PID for stable brew temperature, while the Kenmore offers an optimal 9.0 bar pump pressure and auto-tamping for consistent extraction. Both excel in different aspects of precision.

Limited counter space with frequent milk drink preparation

Koolatron

The Kenmore integrates a bean grinder, auto tamper, and milk steamer/frother into one unit, streamlining the process for cappuccinos and lattes with less clutter.

Who Should Buy Which?

Find the right product for your needs

Breville Barista Express Espresso Machine BES870BTR, Black Truffle - Home Espresso Machines

Buy Breville if...

Breville Barista Express Espresso

The ideal buyer for the Breville Barista Express BES870BTR is an aspiring home barista or coffee enthusiast eager to learn and master the art of espresso making. They value consistency and control above all, appreciating advanced features like PID temperature control which ensures stable brew water temperature for optimal extraction, a critical factor for repeatable quality. This user genuinely enjoys the hands-on ritual of making coffee, from grinding fresh beans directly into the 54.0mm portafilter using the integrated grinder with dose control, to manually steaming milk with the dedicated wand to achieve perfect microfoam. Their priorities include excellent shot quality and the ability to customize variables like grind size and dose, but they also appreciate smart convenience features like the incredibly fast 0.5-minute heat-up time, meaning less waiting for their morning brew. With a budget around $700, they seek a machine that offers substantial capabilities and quality without the high price tag of a full-manual commercial setup. They are willing to put in the effort to refine their technique and are less concerned with full automation, understanding that the learning curve contributes significantly to the overall satisfaction of a perfectly pulled shot. They willingly forego the Koolatron Kenmore's extensive automation for more granular control over their coffee craft.

Koolatron Kenmore Espresso Machine - Automatic Coffee Maker With Auto Tamper, Auto Cleaning, Milk Steamer & Frother, Bean Grinder, Make Professional Barista Style Cappuccino, Latte, Stainless Steel - Home Espresso Machines

Buy Koolatron if...

Kenmore Espresso Machine -

The Koolatron Kenmore Espresso Machine is perfectly suited for the busy individual or household that prioritizes convenience, speed, and consistent results with minimal daily effort. This buyer desires professional-style coffee beverages like cappuccinos and lattes without the need to learn complex barista techniques or engage in the manual ritual of espresso making. Their priorities lean heavily towards automation and ease of use; they want to press a button and have their coffee ready, from grinding to tamping to frothing. The machine's comprehensive suite of automatic features, such as the integrated bean grinder, automatic tamper for consistent puck preparation, a built-in milk steamer and frother, and especially the invaluable auto-cleaning function, are major attractions. They appreciate the optimal 9.0 bar pump pressure, knowing it contributes to good extraction without needing any manual adjustment or pressure profiling. This user is comfortable with a higher price point, around $950, for the advanced automation and the promise of significantly reduced daily maintenance and interaction. They might have a smaller kitchen and prefer a single, integrated appliance that handles all steps from bean to delicious cup. They are less interested in micro-adjusting grind settings or manually texturing milk and are willing to trade that level of hands-on control for the Kenmore's effortless, repeatable performance and comprehensive convenience.

Spec Comparison

9 specs compared

Specification
Breville Barista Express Espresso Machine BES870BTR, Black Truffle - Home Espresso Machines
Breville Barista Express Espresso
Koolatron Kenmore Espresso Machine - Automatic Coffee Maker With Auto Tamper, Auto Cleaning, Milk Steamer & Frother, Bean Grinder, Make Professional Barista Style Cappuccino, Latte, Stainless Steel - Home Espresso Machines
Koolatron Kenmore Espresso Machine
Price$700$952
Rating4.5(27.5k)5.0(4)
Boiler Typethermoblockthermoblock
Pump Pressure Bars159
Portafilter Size mm54
Steam WandYesYes
Model NumberBES870BTR
Grinder IncludedYesYes
Heat Up Time Mins0.5
Water Reservoir oz67
PID Temperature ControlYes

Swipe horizontally to see all columns

Pros & Cons

Quick overview of strengths and weaknesses

Breville Barista Express Espresso Machine BES870BTR, Black Truffle

Breville Barista Express

Pros
  • PID ensures stable brew water temperature.
  • Integrated grinder with dose control.
  • Manual steam wand for milk texturing.
  • Low pressure pre-infusion for even extraction.
Cons
  • Non-standard 54mm portafilter limits accessory choice.
  • Integrated grinder may lack precision of dedicated unit.
Koolatron Kenmore Espresso Machine - Automatic Coffee Maker With Auto Tamper, Auto Cleaning, Milk Steamer & Frother, Bean Grinder, Make Professional Barista Style Cappuccino, Latte, Stainless Steel

Koolatron Kenmore Espresso

Pros
  • 9 bar pump pressure for optimal espresso extraction.
  • Integrated bean grinder for fresh coffee preparation.
  • Automatic tamper ensures consistent tamping pressure.
  • Built-in milk steamer and frother for milk drinks.
Cons
  • Thermoblock boiler may offer less temperature stability.
  • Integrated grinder means single point of failure.
  • Automatic tamper removes manual control over tamping.

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about this comparison

Does the Breville Barista Express heat up quickly?

Yes, the Breville Barista Express has a very fast heat-up time of just 0.5 minutes, allowing for quick espresso preparation.

What portafilter size does the Breville Barista Express use?

It uses a non-standard 54.0mm portafilter. While effective, this may limit accessory choices compared to 58mm commercial sizes.

What is the pump pressure of the Koolatron Kenmore?

The Koolatron Kenmore features a 9.0 bar pump pressure, which is considered optimal for achieving ideal espresso extraction.

Do either of these machines include a grinder?

Yes, both the Breville Barista Express and the Koolatron Kenmore Espresso Machine come with an integrated bean grinder.

Does the Koolatron Kenmore offer temperature stability features like PID?

While the Breville explicitly states PID, the Koolatron Kenmore does not list PID temperature control, which might imply less temperature consistency.

Is the Kenmore machine difficult to clean?

No, the Koolatron Kenmore features an auto-cleaning function, significantly reducing the manual effort required for maintenance.

Explore Other Categories

Popular comparisons across the site

Ask AI

Get instant answers about specs

Get the Deets

Ask our AI assistant

Ask Deets anything!