Breville Barista Express vs Breville Barista Express: Which Should You Buy in 2026?

Name: Breville Barista Express Espresso Machine BES870BSXL, Black Sesame
Brand: Breville
SKU: B00DS4767K
Price: 699.95 USD
Availability: InStock
Rating: 4.4 (27177 reviews)

Our Verdict

Tie Wins

Both Product A (BES870BSXL) and Product B (BES870XL) are essentially the same Breville Barista Express model, offering identical core specifications including a 15-bar pump pressure, thermoblock heating, and integrated conical burr grinders. The only notable differences are the aesthetic finish and a negligible price variance, with Product B being marginally cheaper at $689.99 compared to Product A's $699.95. The better pick is purely a matter of preferred kitchen aesthetic and a very slight budget consideration, as their functional performance is identical.

Bottom Line: Tie is the better choice. Both Product A (BES870BSXL) and Product B (BES870XL) are essentially the same Breville Barista Express model, offering identical core specifications including a 15-bar pump pressure, thermoblock heating, and integrated conical burr grinders.

In-Depth Analysis

How they compare in practice

The Breville Barista Express, represented by both the BES870BSXL (Black Sesame) and BES870XL (Brushed Stainless Steel), stands as a cornerstone in the home espresso machine market for its all-in-one convenience. Fundamentally, these are the same machine, meaning users will experience identical performance and features regardless of which model they choose. Both integrate a conical burr grinder, allowing for fresh grounds on demand and reducing counter clutter. This 'bean to cup in under 60 seconds' design is a major draw for users seeking efficiency in their morning routine.

Key to their performance is the 15-bar pump pressure, designed to extract robust flavor, and PID temperature control, which ensures stable water temperature during brewing—a critical factor for consistent espresso quality. However, as noted in the cons for Product A, the thermoblock heating system, while quick, might not offer the same steam consistency or power as a dedicated boiler found in higher-end machines. This applies equally to both. The manual steam wand, explicitly mentioned for Product B but present on both, offers control over milk texturing for lattes and cappuccinos, albeit requiring some skill to master.

From a practical standpoint, the 54mm portafilter (explicitly mentioned for Product B but standard for this model) is smaller than the commercial 58mm size, which can limit accessory compatibility but is perfectly adequate for home use. The 67 oz water reservoir (explicitly for Product B, but shared) minimizes refill frequency, a convenience for daily users. The primary trade-off between the two models boils down to aesthetics and a small price difference. Product A offers a distinct Black Sesame finish for a unique look, while Product B presents the classic Brushed Stainless Steel. Both are substantial machines, weighing 22.1 lbs and sharing identical dimensions (12.5"W x 13.8"D x 15.9"H), meaning neither offers a space-saving advantage over the other. Ultimately, the choice is cosmetic, backed by identical functionality and value proposition.

Which to Pick for Your Situation

Concrete scenarios with a clear recommendation

For a contemporary kitchen aesthetic

Breville

Product A's unique Black Sesame finish offers a sleek, modern alternative to traditional stainless steel, fitting dark or contemporary kitchen designs.

For the most budget-conscious buyer

Breville

Product B is marginally cheaper at $689.99 compared to Product A's $699.95, offering a slight cost saving for the same core features.

For minimizing water tank refills

Tie

Both machines are the same model and feature a generous 67 oz water reservoir, reducing the frequency of refilling for either choice.

For consistent espresso extraction

Tie

Both models are equipped with PID temperature control and a 15-bar pump pressure, ensuring stable brewing conditions for optimal espresso shots.

Who Should Buy Which?

Find the right product for your needs

Buy Breville if...

Breville Barista Express Espresso

The ideal buyer for the Breville Barista Express BES870BSXL (Black Sesame) is someone who values both high-quality home espresso and distinctive kitchen aesthetics. They are looking for an all-in-one solution that delivers convenience and consistency but also serves as a stylish statement piece on their counter. This individual appreciates the unique 'Black Sesame' finish, preferring a sophisticated, darker appliance to complement their modern or uniquely designed kitchen. They are willing to pay the $699.95 for this specific aesthetic, understanding that the core functional benefits—such as the integrated conical burr grinder, 15-bar pump pressure, and PID temperature control for stable brewing—are identical to the standard model. They prioritize a seamless workflow from bean to cup in under 60 seconds and appreciate the low-pressure pre-infusion for enhanced extraction. While they recognize the slight premium for the finish, they are not swayed by minor price differences, focusing instead on the overall look and the proven reliability of the Barista Express. They don't require external grinders or specialized third-party portafilters, finding the included 54mm sufficient for their needs.

Buy Breville if...

Breville Barista Express Espresso

The Breville Barista Express BES870XL (Brushed Stainless Steel) is perfectly suited for the pragmatic home barista who seeks an exceptional all-in-one espresso experience with a classic, versatile aesthetic. This buyer values proven performance and a comprehensive feature set without unnecessary frills or a premium for a specific color. At $689.99, it offers a slight cost advantage while delivering the exact same high-performance capabilities as its color variant. They appreciate the timeless 'Brushed Stainless Steel' finish, which effortlessly integrates into any kitchen décor. Key priorities for this buyer include the convenience of the integrated conical burr grinder for fresh coffee and the precision of PID temperature control, ensuring consistently delicious espresso shots. The substantial 67 oz water reservoir appeals to their desire for efficiency, minimizing interruptions for refills. While the 54mm portafilter might be a consideration for some, this buyer recognizes it as standard for the machine's class and is prepared to develop their milk texturing skills with the manual steam wand. They are looking for a reliable, capable machine that provides excellent value and a foundation for home espresso exploration, rather than a niche aesthetic statement.

Spec Comparison

9 specs compared

Specification	Breville Barista Express Espresso	Breville Barista Express Espresso
Price	$700	$690
Rating	4.4(27.2k)	4.5(27.1k)
Boiler Type	thermoblock	thermoblock
Pump Pressure Bars	15	15
Portafilter Size mm	—	54
Grinder Included	Yes	Yes
PID Temperature Control	Yes	Yes
Steam Wand	—	Yes
Weight	—	22.1 lbs
Dimensions	—	12.5" × 15.9" × 13.8"
Water Reservoir oz	—	67

Swipe horizontally to see all columns

Pros & Cons

Quick overview of strengths and weaknesses

Breville Barista Express

Pros

Integrated conical burr grinder for fresh grounds
PID temperature control ensures stable brewing
Low-pressure pre-infusion enhances extraction
Espresso ready from bean to cup in under 60s

Cons

Thermoblock design may impact steam consistency
Integrated grinder might limit grind consistency
Can be noisy during grinding and brewing cycles

Breville Barista Express

Pros

Integrated burr grinder saves counter space.
PID control stabilizes brew water temperature.
Low pressure pre-infusion aids even flavor draw.
Manual steam wand allows milk texture control.

Cons

54mm portafilter limits basket compatibility.
Manual milk texturing requires learned skill.
Large physical dimensions may consume counter space.
22.1 lb weight makes unit less portable.

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about this comparison

What is the primary difference between these two Breville Barista Express models?

The main difference is cosmetic: Product A features a Black Sesame finish, while Product B has a Brushed Stainless Steel finish. There's also a minor price variance, with Product B being slightly less expensive.

Do both machines include an integrated coffee grinder?

Yes, both the BES870BSXL and BES870XL models come with an integrated conical burr grinder, allowing you to grind fresh coffee beans directly into the portafilter before brewing.

What portafilter size do these espresso machines use?

Both Breville Barista Express machines utilize a 54mm portafilter, which is standard for this series and ensures consistent extraction for home espresso enthusiasts.

How long does it take to make an espresso with these machines?

Both models are designed for speed, allowing you to go from bean to delicious espresso in under 60 seconds, thanks to their efficient heating and grinding systems.

Do these machines have temperature control for brewing?

Absolutely. Both the Black Sesame and Brushed Stainless Steel versions include PID temperature control, which ensures stable water temperature throughout the espresso extraction process for optimal flavor.

Are there any differences in their steaming capabilities?

No, both machines employ a thermoblock heating system for steam. While effective, this design might offer similar steam consistency and power compared to dedicated boiler systems, meaning no difference between the two.