Our Verdict
Calphalon BVCLECMP1 Temp iQ Espresso Machine Wins

While slightly pricier at $349.99 compared to Amaste's $319.99, the Calphalon offers superior espresso consistency and quality thanks to its PID temperature control and a professional 58mm portafilter, which significantly aids in even extraction. Both utilize a 15-bar pump, but Calphalon's additional features are crucial for a better brew. The Amaste Amaste Espresso Machine is the better pick for those prioritizing an all-in-one solution and convenience with its integrated grinder and lower initial cost.
Bottom Line: Calphalon BVCLECMP1 Temp iQ Espresso Machine is the better choice. While slightly pricier at $349.
In-Depth Analysis
How they compare in practice
The Amaste AC-517EA and Calphalon BVCLECMP1 both offer competent home espresso experiences, each with distinct advantages. The most significant differentiator lies in their approach to convenience versus quality control. The Amaste machine distinguishes itself with an integrated conical burr grinder, featuring 15 grind settings. This all-in-one design streamlines the coffee-making process, making it highly appealing for users with limited counter space or those who value simplicity and don't wish to purchase a separate grinder. Its 68 oz water tank also supports fewer refills, enhancing daily usability. However, it uses a 51mm portafilter, which is less common and limits accessory compatibility compared to the industry-standard size.In contrast, the Calphalon BVCLECMP1 prioritizes shot quality and consistency. It foregoes an integrated grinder, necessitating a separate purchase, but in return, it provides essential features for superior espresso. The inclusion of PID temperature control is a game-changer, maintaining precise and stable water temperature during extraction, which is critical for preventing sour or bitter shots. Furthermore, its 58mm portafilter is the commercial standard, allowing for more even coffee extraction and offering a vast array of aftermarket tampers, baskets, and other accessories. While both machines boast a 15-bar pump and thermoblock heating systems for quick warm-up, the Calphalon's PID and larger portafilter give it an edge in terms of the final beverage's taste profile and consistency.The trade-off is clear: the Amaste offers a convenient, budget-friendly entry into espresso with its grinder included at $319.99. It's perfect for beginners or those seeking an uncomplicated setup. The Calphalon, priced at $349.99, requires an additional investment in a grinder but promises more control over the extraction process and higher potential for quality, appealing to enthusiasts willing to invest in their craft. For comparable water tank capacities (Amaste's 68oz vs Calphalon's 67.628oz), the choice boils down to immediate convenience versus long-term quality and customization potential.
Key Differences
The most significant spec differences at a glance
Portafilter Size
12% lessGrinder Included
100% moreWater Reservoir
1% moreAdvantages
Where each product wins
Amaste
- Grinder Included: 100% higher (True vs False)
- Water Reservoir: 1% higher (68 vs 67.628)
Calphalon
- Portafilter Size: 12% higher (51 vs 58)
Which to Pick for Your Situation
Concrete scenarios with a clear recommendation
For the budget-conscious beginner seeking an all-in-one setup
AmasteThe Amaste comes with an integrated conical burr grinder and is priced lower at $319.99, making it a convenient and economical entry point.
For users prioritizing espresso shot consistency and quality
CalphalonThe Calphalon features PID temperature control for stable brewing temperatures and a 58mm portafilter for optimal extraction, crucial for discerning palates.
For home baristas wanting standard accessories and future upgrade potential
CalphalonThe Calphalon's 58mm portafilter is an industry standard, providing access to a wider range of aftermarket accessories and tools.
For small apartments or limited counter space
AmasteThe Amaste's integrated grinder consolidates two essential components into one machine, saving valuable kitchen real estate.
Who Should Buy Which?
Find the right product for your needs
Buy Amaste if...
Amaste Espresso Machine with
The Amaste Amaste Espresso Machine with Grinder (AC-517EA) is an ideal choice for the aspiring home barista who values convenience, simplicity, and an integrated solution within a reasonable budget. This user often has limited counter space or prefers a streamlined setup, avoiding the need for a separate coffee grinder. They are looking for an easy entry into the world of espresso, wanting to grind fresh beans, pull a shot, and froth milk for lattes or cappuccinos without a complex learning curve or additional purchases. The Amaste's integrated conical burr grinder, featuring 15 customizable grind settings, makes fresh grinding effortless and immediately accessible. Its substantial 68 oz water tank ensures fewer refills, perfect for daily use or serving a small household. Priced at $319.99, it offers a complete espresso station. While the 51mm portafilter isn't the commercial standard, it effectively serves their purpose for enjoyable home brews. This buyer is willing to forgo the precise temperature control (PID) and the wider accessory compatibility of a 58mm portafilter in favor of an uncomplicated, all-in-one machine that gets them brewing quickly and affordably.
Buy Calphalon if...
Calphalon BVCLECMP1 Temp iQ
The Calphalon BVCLECMP1 Temp iQ Espresso Machine with Steam Wand is tailored for the espresso enthusiast who prioritizes shot quality, consistency, and the potential for a truly excellent brew, even if it means a slightly higher initial investment and the purchase of a separate grinder. This buyer is likely a burgeoning home barista keen on honing their craft and appreciates the importance of stable brewing parameters. They understand that precise temperature control is paramount for extracting the best flavors from coffee beans, making the Calphalon's PID temperature control a non-negotiable feature. Furthermore, the machine’s professional 58mm portafilter is a significant draw, providing better, more even extraction and compatibility with a vast ecosystem of standard barista tools and accessories. At $349.99, they are investing in foundational features that directly impact drink quality. This user is comfortable with the manual steam wand and is prepared to master their frothing technique. They are willing to overlook the absence of an integrated grinder, recognizing that a dedicated, high-quality grinder often outperforms built-in options and is a worthwhile separate investment for achieving superior, consistent espresso results.
Spec Comparison
8 specs compared
| Specification | ![]() | ![]() |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $320 | $350 |
| Rating | 4.1(158) | 4.3(4.2k) |
| Boiler Type | Thermoblock | thermoblock |
| Pump Pressure Bars | 15 | 15 |
| Portafilter Size mm | 51 | 58 |
| Steam Wand | Yes | Yes |
| Model Number | AC-517EA | BVCLECMP1 |
| Grinder Included | Yes | No |
| Water Reservoir oz | 68 | 67.63 |
| PID Temperature Control | — | Yes |
Swipe horizontally to see all columns
Pros & Cons
Quick overview of strengths and weaknesses
Amaste Espresso Machine
- Integrated conical burr grinder
- 15 grind settings for customization
- 15-bar pump with visual pressure gauge
- Low-pressure pre-infusion feature
- 51mm portafilter limits accessory choice
- Lacks PID for precise temperature control
Calphalon BVCLECMP1 Temp
- 15-bar pump ensures consistent espresso pressure.
- PID temperature control maintains shot consistency.
- 58mm portafilter delivers even coffee extraction.
- 2.0L water reservoir minimizes frequent refills.
- No integrated coffee grinder.
- Manual steam wand requires user technique.
Frequently Asked Questions
Common questions about this comparison
Which machine provides more consistent espresso shots?
The Calphalon BVCLECMP1 offers superior consistency due to its PID temperature control, which actively maintains stable brewing temperatures for each shot.
Does either espresso machine include a coffee grinder?
Yes, the Amaste Espresso Machine includes an integrated conical burr grinder with 15 grind settings for convenience. The Calphalon does not.
What is the difference in portafilter size and why does it matter?
The Amaste uses a 51mm portafilter, while the Calphalon uses a 58mm. A 58mm portafilter is considered standard, allowing for more even extraction and access to more accessories.
Are both machines suitable for making lattes and cappuccinos?
Yes, both the Amaste and Calphalon machines are equipped with a steam wand, enabling users to froth milk for various milk-based coffee drinks.
How do the water reservoir capacities compare?
The Amaste has a 68 oz water tank, while the Calphalon has a 67.628 oz reservoir. Both offer generous capacity to reduce frequent refills.
Which machine offers better value for money?
The Amaste ($319.99) offers great value for an all-in-one solution. The Calphalon ($349.99) provides better value for quality-focused users due to its PID and 58mm portafilter, despite needing a separate grinder.
Explore Other Categories
Popular comparisons across the site
Ask AI
Get instant answers about specs
Get the Deets
Ask our AI assistant
Ask Deets anything!





























